It's a very bad eye pencil because it tends to break every time though it's color pay off is good but you can't use your pencil half because of breaking.

An amazing product that stays on for a super long time.

Perfect!! Never get smudged, stays longer. My all-time fav.

This pencil is magical stays all day long n pigmentation is unreal

This is the first time I am disappointed with Bobbi Brown. No doubt the kajal glides smoothly but it smudges with an hour. I applied an extremely thin line on my upper lid but it smudged didn't work for me Not as a liner neither as kajal.

Complete waste of money. Messy and Spreads after. 15 minutes of application. There are way too many brands far better then bobbi brown brand. A big no for this product..

I have been using this for 2 years and I must say the best one available in the market.

I loved the way the color stood out and did not smudge. It was amazing. Planning to get the other colors too.

I use it as eyeliner, I apply it in the morning around 8:30 before leaving for office and it stays intact when I come back at around 7:30. It is the best. Even better than Mac eyeliners. Easy to remove with makeup remover and it doesn't leave a black stain on eyelid after use. A bit expensive but totally worth the money.

Easy to apply smooth texture. I love this kajal.

Awesome product of Bobbi.. No Smudge.. Easy to Remove..

it's highly pigmented, stays for so long, glides on smoothly and doesn't irritate the eyes. totally waterproof and smudge proof.

This doesn’t smudge at all.. just stays in the place which is the most I want from an eye pencil.

I have tried quite a few brands. This is a must for working women.. stays long, doesn’t smudge (no more coming home looking like a raccoon). One pencil lasts me 3-4 months easily. So while expensive you don’t need the run to the store every month!! I’ve completely switched over to B.B. from mac

Really long stay, does not smudge, Jet is a Lovely intense black colour

Great creamy texture, glides easily on the eyelids as well. Excellent for use as an eyeliner, no smudges!

I have tried a lot of kohl pencils including mac and inglot...but this one is way superior...will stock up on more shades too

Like the texture of the pencil: firm yet creamy. It goes on smoothly and lasts well especially on the upper lid.

Doesn’t smudge, very smooth application!

best eye pencil i have used till this date. smooth texture. gives really dark colour when drawn on waterline. Stays long. easy to remove.